Movie Review: Eternity

Runtime: 1h 52m

Genre: Fantasy / Romantic Comedy

Verdict: Refreshing concept and great cast, but fumbled the ending.

The Premise

Eternity takes the classic love triangle and elevates it with a high-stakes, metaphysical twist. Joan (Elizabeth Olsen) finds herself in the afterlife facing an impossible choice when she is reunited with both of the loves of her life. On one side is Luke (Callum Turner), her first husband who died tragically young in war, representing the intense "what if" of interrupted youth. On the other is Larry Cutler (Miles Teller), her second husband with whom she shared a devoted happy 65-year marriage, representing the deep, lived-in bond of a lifetime partnership. The catch is that she must choose only one of them to spend eternity with, forcing a heartbreaking a debate of the 'impossible' choice.

The 'Impossible' Choice 

The film’s greatest strength lies in how genuinely difficult it makes the central dilemma. It refuses to villainize either husband or present an obvious "right" answer, perfectly balancing the distinct appeal of both relationships. This is bolstered by impeccable casting. Elizabeth Olsen anchors the film brilliantly, conveying the overwhelming emotional weight of her decision without losing her charm. She is supported by Callum Turner, who brings a tragic, magnetic quality to Luke, and Miles Teller, who delivers a warm, grounded performance as Larry, proving that stability can be just as compelling as passion. The chemistry between the three leads is what makes the concept work, as you truly believe Joan loved both of them profoundly. The supporting cast also had brilliant performance and helping Joan make the decision. It's chaotic, it's fun, it's entertaining and the concept is unique and refreshing. 

The Ending (Spoiler Free)

For most of its runtime, the film is a masterclass in emotional storytelling, but it unfortunately stumbles at the finish line. There is a specific moment near the end that feels like the perfect conclusion when Joan makes her first decision. However, the movie decides to keep going which had me perplexed. The last 15 to 20 minutes effectively undo the impact of that perfect stopping point, dragging the story into a resolution that doesn't feel wrong or bad, but it's not perfect. The movie had the perfect ending but decided to wreck it. It is a classic case of a film not knowing exactly when to roll the credits. The ending was only possible due to the plot armour. But the movie tried to convey a message with the ending it finally went with.

The Verdict 

Eternity is a soul-stirring romance with a intriguing hook and a trio of fantastic performances. While the final 20 minutes prevent it from being a masterpiece, the journey is still well worth taking. It is a film that will leave you debating what you would do in Joan's shoes long after it ends.

Rating: ★★★¾ (3.75/5)